For every steak, you can make a compound butter that will elevate your experience. Either for your family dinner nights or when you host some guest and want to take that extra little step to make sure your meal will be satisfying! The best part of compound butter is there are so many variations to them, basically, once you start making them you will find yourself creating your combinations in no time.

Smokehouse blue cheeseSmoke House Blue Cheese is a blue cheese that is smoked with hickory, apple or even cherry wood to provide a sweet and light smokey flavor. I love to pair it with my steaks whenever possible, Ribeye steaks, Filet Mignon, or NY Strip steaks. For this recipe, I crisped up some hickory bacon and then added it to the butter with some of the smokehouse blue cheese. This combination did not disappoint and was definitely a crowd-pleaser. Okay, let’s jump into the recipe!

seasoned strip steak

Smoke House Blue Cheese Bacon NY Strip Steaks

Prep Time 20 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes
Course Main Course
Cuisine American
Servings 3


  • 3 NY Strip steaks Prime or better
  • 2 tbsp Salt
  • 2 tbsp Pepper
  • 2 tbsp Garlic powder
  • Duck fat

Smoke House Blue Cheese Bacon Butter

  • 8 oz Unssalted butter softened
  • ½ cup Crispy diced bacon ¾ cup if you love bacon!
  • ½ cup Scallions diced
  • 6 oz Smoke house blue cheese softened
Keyword blue cheese sauce, easy steak recipe, NY Strip steak, smoked strip steaks, smokehouse blue cheese, strip steak recipe
  1. Start off by sitting your butter out in room temp for 1-2 hours, you want it to be soft. At this point get your bacon and cut it into small cubes (dice it up) and place a cast-iron skillet over medium heat. Add the bacon and crisp, once crisp place it to the side.
  2. Crumble your smokehouse blue cheese and Chop your scallions.
  3. In a medium-sized bowl add the butter and add the smokehouse blue cheese, bacon, and scallions. Mix with a fork until it is well combined. 
  4. Stretch some plastic wrap out over your cutting board and spread the butter mixture out evenly as possible. Now roll it into a uniformed butter log and twist off your ends. Place in the fridge for 50-60 mins.
  5. Be sure your NY Strip steaks are room temp and pat them dry. Now add a teaspoon or two of duck fat to your steaks and spread it across the whole surface. Add the salt, pepper and garlic powder into a mixing bowl and combine. Season your steaks generously and let them sit for 25 minutes.
  6. I used my gas grill here so I fired it up and put it to medium heat (425-450). I let my grill warm-up for 15 minutes and then added my steaks. I let them cook for 2 minutes and then rotated them 45 degrees and cooked them for another 2 minutes. From here I flipped them and repeated. Be sure to check the internal temperatures of your steaks, I wanted a 125 internal temp for my medium-rare liking. After you flip the steak the first time be sure to get your Smoke House Blue Cheese Bacon Butter out and cut a few tablespoons for each steak. 20-30 seconds prior to pulling your steaks off the grill add the butter to the steaks to melt on the grill. If your steaks are ready to be pulled off just add the butter while resting and place aluminum foil on top or use a torch to melt the butter. 
  7. Let rest for 10-12 minutes and spread the butter across your steaks, this helps to have that flavor with every bite. 
  8. Slice and serve, Enjoy with family and friends!

 Smoke House Blue Cheese Bacon New York Strip Steaks are a delicious and easy way to enjoy a fantastic steak dinner. The recipe is simple, and the results are mouth-watering. If you’re looking for an impressive dish to serve your family or guests, this is definitely it. So why not give it a try? You won’t be disappointed.

Did you enjoy this Smoke House blue cheese NY Strip steak recipe? Find more beef recipes by clicking the link below!

Beef Recipes

Items used in this recipe

Napoleon Phantom

Mixing Bowls

Nitrile Gloves

Leave a Reply